Bookmark and Share
My Photo


    Opinions expressed on the Insight Scoop weblog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the positions of Ignatius Press. Links on this weblog to articles do not necessarily imply agreement by the author or by Ignatius Press with the contents of the articles. Links are provided to foster discussion of important issues. Readers should make their own evaluations of the contents of such articles.


« Benedict XVI on St. Francis of Assisi, "a great saint and a joyful man" | Main | Rabbi Neusner: Benedict XVI told me he's written his last book »

Wednesday, January 27, 2010


maria horvath

All this anger and consternation about a 30-second commercial that tells a happy story. These women are pathetic.


I'm happy that a pro-life message might be played during the Super Bowl, but on a side note, I'm sick of the Tim Tebow praise. He and his family are anti-Catholic bigots. Period. His father's "ministry" in the Philippines is aggresively trying to break Philipinnos away from the Church. He claims that 75% of the country has never even been exposed to the Gospels. Funny, since 80% of the country is Catholic.


Actually they are right, to a degree:

FOF thinks abortion is wrong. Gay sex is wrong. It should be discouraged. Period.

That is what makes them hysterical.

We should stop pretending we have reasonable common ground. We do not. We are against sin. They are not.

M. Jordan Lichens

I first need to state that I am a recovering cynic. That being said, the fact that the pro-choice lobby is frothing at the mouth over a thirty second commercial being aired during the Super Bowl amidst thousands of other adverts which denigrate women (I'm basing this on previous adverts, oops there I go with my prejudice) and are calling for market censorship while being unable to offer a coherent arguement for their side gives me little hope for the survival of our nation past this next generation. I can only hope that we millennials see the silliness of the Boomers and finally say, "Enough is enough."


This is clearly not about choice, and it never has been.

That is why the movement is properly called the pro-abortion movement.


First I would like for M. Jordan Lichens to help ME become a 'recovering cynic.' I am most certainly not in recovery.


If men had a right to murder, and if the embyro wasn't a person, than she'd have a point.


By the way, I included the wrong link in the above comment. Here is the one I meant to include:

J D Hill

Joy Behar and her ilk are at best a herd of braying asses, and at worst to depraved to endure.


I am glad that the Tebow commercial is taking that angle. The only reason I didn't abort my oldest two children is because I did not have the money for abortions. (I was a fallen away Catholic then and pro-abortion). They were born under really bad circumstances - I was not married, my boyfriend was an abusive alcoholic who was perpetually unemployed so he could hang out in bars as much as he wanted, I had a low-paying job, I felt hopeless and depressed all the time. The children have grown to be very intelligent, talented and beautiful, kind and thoughtful teenagers. (My daughter sends me a bouquet every Mother's Day). Probably a thousand times I have superimposed in my mind torn, broken, aborted little bodies and my lovely children as they are now, as opposed to what they might have ended up as and it just horrifies me to tears. Circumstances can and do change. I'm married now to a great guy and we have a nice family. And the oldest are a big help now with my little ones, babysit, etc. Feminism can and does take an ugly turn, and Joy Behar wants us to be able to kill our babies and then live with that (because it allows us to be immoral with impunity). Rather than the happy and fulfilling choice that God is offering us. We Catholics are not miserable or misguided as she thinks we are and I think that angers her.


While I do not support abortion, I think you misinterpret Behar's position. I don't think she is implicitly or explicity suggesting that it would be alright to abort "rapist pedophiles."

I think her point was that the Tebow add presents a consequentialist argument against abortion. In other words, the fact that Tebow is a decent person has no bearing on whether his mother should or should not have had the abortion. To a degree, I think Behar has point. It does not matter if the life in the womb is going to be a future Tebow or a future Obama or a future Stalin. That is not the point or even a consideration when considering the morality of abortion. The Tebow add is making an emotional appeal against abortion rather than a strictly logical or moral one. That is fine with me. I've never met an argument against abortion that I didn't like. Be that as it may, I don't think you construal of Behar's comments is a fair one.


Hey, don't blame ALL us Boomers for this silliness. Some of us were on the front lines long ago saying, "But...but..." We just got outshouted by the coat-hanger crowd, and the next thing you know, brainless and spineless folks were voting to kill babies because of something that MIGHT happen if they weren't allowed to do that.

But it's unfair to blame it all on Boomers, either. We Boomers were propagandized by people older and "wiser" than we were--in other words, the generation ahead of us. I have great hope that Millennials will erase much of this nonsense...if they've been lucky enough to be raised by Boomers who actually taught them right and wrong. And we ARE out here, folks. We're getting laughed at, ridiculed, and shoved in the corner as irrelevant, but we're still out here, and it's as unfair to paint us all with the same brush as it is for Tim Tebow's father's ministry to assume that they're actually bringing the Gospel to the Philippines. Propaganda is propaganda. Let's try not to blindly repeat one lie while decrying another...


Fr Eric

Thomas is correct about the Tebow family. I grow weary of the fundamentalists and Non-Denoms who travel the world to bring Jesus to Catholics.

YET, O'Reilly is adept at what is going on. The Tebows had their baby. They made a choice for life and they are happy. The pro-abortion group is incensed that anything good could come of having a baby in the midst of a difficult pregnancy.


That ending was hilarious Carl!!! All of this just shows how these women know they are wrong about what they believe. They are afraid of a little commercial for a reason. They know people are starting to see through them. I'm so sick of these hard core feminists acting like they care about women. They do not speak for me. If it were up to them, children would not exist and men would probably all be gay, yuckk!! A baby is never a choice, it is a life. The choice was deciding whether to have sex outside of marriage or not.

Sandra Miesel

If the Superbowl can run Scientology commercials, why not pro-life ones? Oh, that's. . . different.

Linda DeMerle

I fired Joy Behar years ago. The fact that this woman was a teacher makes my blood run cold. For a former Catholic or however she couches it, she is grossly uninformed and unqualified to speak on Catholicism. She makes outrageous remarks and assumes that her status as a comedian gives her the right to do that, yet wants people to take her seriously. In short, she wants to have her cake and eat it, too. Well, she stopped being funny, if she ever was, a very long time ago and is the reason I do not watch The View any longer.

Francis Beckwith

Imagine the commercial featured two men engaging in an open-mouthed kiss and Focus on the Family objected. Behar would call them narrow-minded intolerant bigots.

In this commercial, Mrs. Tebow explains why she believes the human community you ought to love is wider than the set of people you choose. And Behar objects. I guess that would make her the bigot.

Joy Behar, an irony rich environment.

Gene Branaman

"She makes outrageous remarks and assumes that her status as a comedian gives her the right to do that, yet wants people to take her seriously."

Behar is a comedian? Wow. Didn't know that. I find quite a lot that she says to be funny. But, I'm sure she doesn't intend as funny what I laugh at. And my laughter is not the same as it would be were I reading Wodehouse. I'm also sure, were she to read this post, that she'd not understand what I'm talking about.

And I think so very many folk will have egg on their faces after they've actually SEEN the ad. But I'd lay money they won't ever bring it up again! Especially not Behar & her ilk.


She said more than the baby might be a rapist. A few moments later she said abortion "is just a procedure".
Like removing a mole or having liposuction, I guess.

David Casson

" me little hope for the survival of our nation past this next generation. I can only hope that we millennials see the silliness of the Boomers and finally say, "Enough is enough." - M. Jordan Lichens

Right on, MJL. I am a fellow Millennial (born 1986) and whether the world likes it or not, I am a completely satisfied Catholic. I wouldn't have it any other way. And I'm glad to hear you're a recovering cynic; I hope you'll let it die for good. The truth is, Christ Himself is the death of our cynicism. In Him our hope is boundless. Our generation is going to mirror every generation that preceded it: there will be those who protest, those who don't care, and finally there will be those who in every way possible strive to make available the light of Christ to all people everywhere, knowing that all people were made, ultimately, to enjoy the unparalleled love God has for us. Whether as friends, lovers, or martyrs, we will walk in the footsteps of the Christians who lived before us, and we will pass on the Faith to the next generation. Why? 'Cause that's what the Church does.

Julie - may God bless you abundantly, and may He bless your children abundantly, too.

Jay Everett

Why are we so concerned today with something that has been going on since time began? We are so caught up in entertainment that we have no life of our own. This subject of life and death is not entertainment. It is a way to make money (lots of it) at the expense of fools. By the way, WE HAVE MET THE FOOLS AND THEY IS US!!!


As you can see we are reacting exactly as they want us to. You only have to read the comments. Why not avoid the occasion of sin by not watching or listening to this dribble on the TV? Jay Everett is right not only are we being fools but they know it and without our complaints they would have no show. So turn your attention to the Church, whichever denomination, and look at all the blessings that can be obtained. AVOID EVIL and live in the light of GOD.

c marks

it is not the pro abortion movement. It's the right to chose movement. The decision is between a woman, her family, and her doctor, not anyone else. No one has the right to decide for women. you pro life people are too much, you don't want any babies killed , but you will commit cold blooded murder of anyone you don't agree with, such as doctors.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Ignatius Insight


Ignatius Press

Catholic World Report


Blogs & Sites We Like

June 2018

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Blog powered by Typepad