... and I'll do my best to bumble through the answers. Case in point, some questions from a college student who is working on a paper about Christianity in America. Here are some of her questions, along with my answers:
Do you have any comments on the current health state of American Christianity?
It is common to hear two extremes: that America is teetering on the edge of a radical, right-wing theocracy that will soon strip non-Christians of their rights, or that America is now thoroughly pagan and "post-Christian" in nature, having abandoned its Christian beliefs in the 1960s. I think that neither of these notions is accurate, but they do offer some insight, however skewed, into what is a very complex and murky matter. I believe it was Chesterton who remarked that America has the soul of a church. I think there is still some truth to that, but I also believe that the "church" in question has increasingly become a hazy form of "whatever works for me" spirituality that clings to vestiges of Christian symbolism, language, and practice while abandoning the core of authentic, orthodox Christianity. This is very common the Northwest, where I live, which is the least churched area of the United States, but is filled with every sort of spirituality and skepticism, including Eastern mysticism, neo-paganism, vague pantheism, neo-Marxism, and everything in-between.
On the other hand, there are substantial pockets, if you will, of orthodox Christianity, both Protestant and Catholic (and Eastern Orthodox). I think that one of the important shifts in American Christianity in recent decades has been the growing respect and trust between many Catholics and Evangelicals, something impossible to imagine just 60 or 70 years ago. And then there is the growing and often blatant chasm between more orthodox, historical Christian traditions, and forms of Christianity that pursue the latest cultural and academic fads: radical feminism, deconstructionism, post-modern relativism, and egalitarianism. Christianity in America faces numerous challenges. But it always has had difficult challenges, and it is more lively and vibrant than what can be found (if it can be found) in Western Europe.
How and when does God enter your thoughts during the course of a day? Could you describe your personal understanding of a graceful God?
I'm fortunate, I suppose, in that much of my work involves reading and editing materials that have to do with theology, so I am regularly considering matters relating to God. The danger is that it can simply become a job. I find that having two young children makes me mindful of God in many ways. For example, being a parent causes to me to see more clearly my many weaknesses and failings, which in turn causes me to turn to God for wisdom and grace. Also, my wife and I believe that we are the primary teachers of our children, so we look for opportunities to instruct them about Jesus, the Church, and the Church. Teaching a weekly Bible study helps me to focus on Scripture and my relationship with God. In our class we always end up discussing the Faith in a way that is both relational and practical; I believe that theology has everything to do with the life of holiness. Once theology becomes merely academic, spiritual rot easily sets in.
As a Christian, I find it more and more important to contemplate, in thought and prayer, the Triune nature of God: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Again, this isn't a matter of abstract theology, but has everything to do with the ground and basis of reality. The Triune God is Relationship: perfect, whole, and loving. I am invited to enter into a life-giving relationship with the Triune God; to become a partaker in the divine nature, through the Son and in the Holy Spirit, because of the loving will of the Father. This reality is expressed in a profound and powerful way in the Liturgy; it is the basis of the liturgical calendar; it is the message of the Bible. As I try to consider and reflect on this each day, even if for just a few moments, it further shapes how I treat others, how I live among my neighbors, and how I fulfill my responsibilities to my community and nation.
How do you think the Catholic understanding of God differs from a Protestant vision of God? How do these different understandings of God affect one's spirituality and worship?
That is almost impossible to answer, largely because I don't think it can be said that there is an understanding of God that most Protestants would share today. Perhaps we could go back to 1520 or 1550 and consider the classical Protestant view of this or that, and compare it to Catholic teaching.
But I think that many Evangelicals share with Catholic and Eastern Orthodox a view of God that is far different than, say, that held by a mainline Protestant who practices yoga, thinks wicca is lovely, and refers to God as "She". But, speaking in very broad terms, I think that Catholics and Eastern Orthodox see the world with a sacramental, incarnational perspective that recognizes that God works in and through the material realm to give us His divine life and grace.
While more and more Evangelicals are appreciating and considering that viewpoint, they tend to see the material realm in a more detached way; they often approach their faith through reading a book, the Bible, rather than living in a Tradition from which that book emerged in an organic way, if you will. There are many exceptions, on both sides, to this general observation, but I think it has validity. And it points to those important places topics that Catholics and Evangelicals need to continue talking about.
Recent Comments